c/board-game-geeks

I used to hoard every rulebook, now I toss them after 1 play

My buddy pointed out I had a shelf sagging under 40 pounds of manuals, so now I snap a photo of the setup and scoring pages and recycle the rest, has anyone else gone digital with their reference sheets?

0 comments

terryk10•11h ago

My 3AM game night ruined by a broken die, looking for a replacement set

Last week I hosted my monthly game night and we cracked open a 15 year old copy of a dice game I got back in 2012. About 2 hours in, one of the d6s split clean in half, no idea how, it just snapped. We tried to keep going with a random penny as a substitute but that killed the vibe real fast. Anyone have a go-to set of dice that actually survive heavy rolling, or should I just buy two of everything from now on?

0 comments

terryk28•5d ago

Our 8 person game night keeps turning into 3 player zone defense

I host a weekly group in Columbus and we've had the same 8 folks for six months. The trouble shows up around turn 3 or 4, someone pulls out their phone and then two others start side conversations about work. By round 6 we might as well be playing three separate games. I've tried shorter games, timers, even a snack break at the halfway mark, but nothing sticks. Is there a way to wrangle people back to the table without being the fun police, or do I just accept that game night is now social hour with dice?

1 comments

the_stella•6d ago

Gloomhaven JotL vs base game, I picked the small box first and honestly glad I did

I finally got into tactical dungeon crawlers last month and had to choose between Gloomhaven and Jaws of the Lion. I went with the $40 JotL box because the rulebook is broken into 5 missions, so you learn one thing at a time instead of getting slammed with 400 pages. Finished scenario 8 last night with a buddy and we only had to look up one edge case about line of sight. The smaller map tiles also fit on my coffee table which is a 3 foot square, so that sealed it. Has anyone else started with the smaller entry and felt like it made the big version less scary or did you just jump straight into the full campaign?

0 comments

garcia.tyler•7d ago

Just realized the odds of rolling snake eyes in my group are way off

I tracked 300 dice rolls in our monthly game night spreadsheet and snake eyes came up 14 times, which is triple the math. Did our cheap dice get warped from staying in a hot car, or has anyone else seen stats like this in their own sessions?

0 comments

oscarc53•14d ago

Vent: I chose the 8 hour eurogame over the 2 hour worker placement every single time now

After 3 months of hosting game nights in Portland, I picked the epic heavy strategy titles over the quick teachable ones because they force everyone to actually talk through their moves, and my group of 5 has stopped checking their phones entirely, so has anyone else found that longer games fixed their table's attention problem?

1 comments

sam_thomas•15d ago

The player aid I laminated got wiped out by one spilled soda

Last Friday at a friend's place in Austin, someone knocked over a Mountain Dew right onto my laminated quick reference cards for a 4-hour campaign game. The lamination actually trapped the liquid inside and made every card unreadable. Have you ever tried to save laminated components, or do you just accept the loss and print new ones?

1 comments

susanm56•16d ago

My buddy's house rule for Catan took 45 minutes to explain

He added a 'pirate tax' where anyone landing on a 7 had to roll again and give half their cards to someone he deemed 'coastal', and the math never worked out the same way twice lol. Has anyone else sat through a house rule that felt like a second rulebook?

1 comments

wesley385•17d ago

The 14th play of Gloomhaven finally made the rulebook click

My group kept messing up monster focus for weeks. We'd finish a scenario and then argue about whether the brute should have moved that way. Last Saturday, on our 14th play, I read the line about 'nearest hex with a path' out loud and it just landed. We played three scenarios back to back without a single rules lookup. Has anyone else had a rule suddenly make sense way later than it should?

1 comments

susanm56•19d ago

Vent: the guy who timed my turns at GameHaven last Saturday

I was at GameHaven in Austin playing a 4 player game of Terraforming Mars, and this random guy walks over to watch. After my third turn he pulls out his phone and says my turn took 6 minutes and 20 seconds, like that's some kind of crime. He then starts giving me tips on how to plan my cards faster, talking to me like I was holding up a tournament, not a casual Saturday game. I told him I play to think, not to speedrun, and he just shrugged and walked off. Has anyone else had a spectator criticize their pace mid-game? How do you shut that down without killing the mood?

2 comments

gavin692•21d ago

That $60 'deluxe' expansion left my group staring at each other for an hour

Bought the big box campaign expansion last month, thought it would add depth, but the rules overwhelmed everyone and we spent the whole session just setting up. The physical components are nice but nobody wants to touch it again after that slog. Anyone else get burned by a hyped expansion that killed their game night?

2 comments

sarah_hart•21d ago

Unpopular take: play-to-win mechanics ruin casual game nights

Last month at the Denver meetup, someone brought a heavy euro game and bragged about their 80% win rate. I get it, some folks enjoy the optimization puzzle, but when one player treats it like a tournament and everyone else is just trying to have fun, it kills the table. I'd rather lose to a lucky dice roll than sit through another 2-hour analysis paralysis session. Anyone else prefer games where luck levels the playing field over pure skill-heavy ones?

1 comments

the_hayden•22d ago

One perfect Tuesday night of 7 Wonders, then a Thursday that flopped entirely

Last Tuesday my regular group of 5 played 7 Wonders with all the expansions and every game came down to the last card, I was buzzing for two days after. Then Thursday we tried the same lineup and two people bailed, the other three just argued about scoring rules and we packed it up after one round. Does anyone else find that a great night makes a bad one feel way worse, or is it just me?

2 comments

hollyl45•23d ago

Overheard a guy at my local game store say he only plays games with zero randomness and it made me rethink my whole collection

I've got about 30 games on my shelf and about 20 of them have dice or card draws, so should I be looking for more euro-style deterministic games or am I overthinking what makes a game fun?

2 comments

henderson.oscar•24d ago

I was dead set against dice tower trays until I saw one stop a cataclysm mid-game

A few months ago, a friend brought a dice tower and tray to game night and I rolled my eyes so hard. I said it was just extra plastic cluttering the table, like, why not just roll in the box lid like we always did? Then during a round of Dune Imperium someone knocked a full bowl of Chex Mix onto the table and that plastic tray caught every single piece before it landed on the board. No reset, no arguing, just wiped it off and kept going. That one split second sold me on the whole concept. Has anyone else been convinced by a specific moment like that, or are you still team 'just roll anywhere'?

2 comments

sanchez.pat•24d ago

I finally had it with the "trading phase" of board games

Overheard a guy at my local game store saying every game needs a trading mechanic to be fun, but I think that's just nonsense. Last month I played a game with zero trading and it was way more strategic - has anyone else seen a group get too hung up on one mechanic?

3 comments

carr.elliot•25d ago

That $90 deluxe insert for Terraforming Mars was a total waste

I bought that big plastic organizer set for all the tiny cubes and cards, but it doesn't even fit back in the box right once everything's assembled. Has anyone else had this problem or found a better storage solution that actually works?

2 comments

christopherwilson•26d ago

Found out Monopoly was originally meant to teach about unfair rent systems

I was reading the rulebook for a new game I picked up last weekend and got curious about where Monopoly actually came from. Turns out it was created in 1904 by a woman named Lizzie Magie as a tool to show how land ownership concentrates wealth. She wanted people to see how rent systems punish the poor. Parker Brothers eventually bought it and turned it into the roll-and-buy game we all know. I found this in a deep dive on a history of board games site. Kinda blew my mind that a game I played as a kid had such a different original point. Has anyone else run into a game's real history that changed how you see it?

2 comments

the_holly•27d ago

Watched a guy at a game cafe sort his entire deck by color before starting a match

Dropped into Mox Boarding House in Seattle last Saturday and this dude spent a solid 10 minutes organizing his cards by shade. Made me wonder if we're all just playing our own little side games while pretending to focus on the main one.

2 comments

emery199•27d ago

Guy at a con last year tried to sell me his 'rare' game for $200

I was walking through the vendor hall at PAX Unplugged in Philly, just browsing, when this guy flags me over. He points to a scratched up copy of some 1990s Euro game I'd never heard of and says it's worth $200 because only 500 copies exist. I asked him if he had the rulebook or any of the missing pieces, and he just shrugged and said 'it's still rare.' Has anyone else run into sellers who think missing pieces don't matter just because it's old?

2 comments

bennett.mason•1mo ago

Paid $60 for a "deluxe" insert for my favorite game and it didn't even fit right.

I got hyped up by the reviews online and dropped $60 on a fancy wooden insert for Terraforming Mars. Spent a whole Saturday afternoon assembling it, only to find the card trays were too narrow. My sleeved cards wouldn't fit, so I had to unsleeve everything just to use the thing. Total waste of money and time. Now I'm back to using baggies like a normal person. Has anyone else had bad luck with these aftermarket organizers?

2 comments

wesley385•1mo ago

I visited a board game cafe in Portland last week and noticed something weird

Every table had at least one person on their phone looking up rules instead of just playing the game. Is this just how people do it now or am I old school for thinking you should learn the game before you sit down?

2 comments

val949•1mo ago

Bought a $200 "beginner" board game collection and regretted it immediately

I saw a deal on a bundle of 5 classic board games for about $200, thinking it'd be a good way to get into the hobby. Turned out three of them had missing pieces, one had a torn board, and the rules were so poorly translated I couldn't make sense of them. Total waste of money, and now I'm stuck trying to piece together replacements or just chucking them. Anyone else get burned by those mystery bundles online?

2 comments

rowanharris•1mo ago

My old gaming group vs my new one - night and day difference

I used to play with a group that treated every game like a competition, even co-op stuff like Pandemic. They would quarterback every move and get grumpy if someone didn't follow their plan. Then last month I joined a new group at a local cafe, and we played Spirit Island where everyone just figured things out together. It was way more fun and actually relaxing. Has anyone else switched groups and noticed a big change in how games feel?

2 comments

jesse_williams62•1mo ago

Finally got my board game group to try a co-op game after 6 months of nothing but competitive stuff

I've been running a weekly game night for my friends since last fall, and it's always been Catan or Ticket to Ride with people getting salty. Last week I brought out Forbidden Island on a whim and figured it'd flop hard. Everyone actually worked together and we won on the last turn before the island sank. Has anyone else had a group that just clicked with co-op after resisting it forever?

2 comments