Wow, that lender's math feels so familiar. It's like how everything gets sold to us now, focusing only on the low monthly hit while hiding the real long-term cost, which totally reminds me of what @jade_johnson just said. You really have to dig into the full picture yourself.
Remember my first place... the lender made the low down payment sound like a total no-brainer. I was so focused on the smaller upfront number that I barely looked at the PMI. Ended up paying an extra two hundred bucks a month for like five years, money that just vanished. It felt like a stupid tax for not running the full math myself.