Serious question, a guy at the Austin con told me my reviews spoil too much and now I cut the plot recaps
I was at a small anime con in Austin back in March and ended up in line for a ramen bowl next to this guy who runs a tiny review channel. He asked what I thought of a show we both watched and I launched into my usual thing, a full rundown of the first three episodes. He cut me off and said, "You just told me the whole story, why would I watch it now?" Honestly it stung at first but he was right, I was doing plot summaries instead of actually saying how a show feels to sit through. So I changed my format, I keep recaps to like one sentence and spend the rest on pacing, art, and whether the side characters carry their weight. My videos are shorter now, about 6 minutes instead of 12, and the comments got way more interesting because people actually argue about my takes instead of just correcting my episode facts. Ngl it was hard to stop myself at first since recapping is easy and having an opinion is scary. Has anyone else been called out like that on how they write or talk about a show, and did you change your style or tell the person off?
That line about recapping being easy and having an opinion being scary hit me hard because I used to be the opposite guy. I figured plot recaps were the safe move, like if I just told people what happened nobody could say I was wrong about anything. Took me a long time to admit that was basically me hiding, and the reviews I actually go back and rewatch from other people are the ones where they just say how the show felt. Your point about the comments getting more interesting is the part that really sold me, because arguing about takes is way more fun than getting fact checked on episode three. Still working on cutting my own recaps down, and yeah it's harder than it looks, your mileage may vary on the six minute thing but I'm aiming for shorter either way.