Cooking pizza on a cast iron griddle sounded wrong until I tried it at a campground
Last summer at a campsite near Lake Okeechobee, some guy pulled out a cast iron griddle and made pizza right over the fire. I figured it would burn the bottom and leave the middle raw, no way that works. He let me watch, he used a cold dough ball and stretched it thin, then put it on a preheated grate with a lid on top. Took about 6 minutes per side and the crust actually got that charred chewy texture I usually only get from my home oven. Now I've done it twice in my own backyard when it's too hot to run the oven inside. Has anyone else had luck with a griddle or skillet instead of a traditional pizza stone? I'm curious if the thickness of the metal matters that much.
Man, I gotta push back on this because a griddle pizza is never gonna match a real stone in a screaming hot oven. The whole point of a pizza stone is it soaks up heat and dumps it into the crust all at once, and cast iron sitting over a fire just can't hold that kind of steady blast. You said 6 minutes per side, which means you're basically making a flatbread and flipping it, that's not the same thing as a true pizza bake at all. And yeah the thickness matters a ton, a thin griddle will spike and drop temp like crazy while a thick one takes forever to heat up evenly, so you're always fighting hot spots either way. I tried this once at a buddy's place and the bottom went black before the top cheese even thought about melting. The backyard thing when it's too hot for the oven makes sense I guess, but calling it real pizza is a stretch lol.