TIL a viewer comment about my thumbnails got me 200 more clicks in a week
I run a small channel about board game reviews, nothing huge, and 3 weeks ago a guy left a comment saying my thumbnails looked like "a pile of gray soup" and he could not tell my videos apart. Kind of stung at first, but he was right. Every thumb was a screenshot of me talking with the same gray wall behind me. So I spent a Sunday in my garage with a $12 poster board and some markers, and now every thumb has one big readable word plus a game piece sitting in the corner. One week later my click rate went from 3.1% to 4.8%, and I got 200 more clicks than my usual Tuesday upload. It is not life changing money or anything, but it felt good to see a number move after months of flat. Now I am curious how far I should push it before it starts looking like everybody else's loud thumbnails. Has anyone here found a line between clear and cheesy with their thumbnails?