Some guy at the Euclid flea market called my $4 cast iron "too far gone" and I nearly walked
I was poking around the outdoor stalls off Euclid Ave a couple Saturdays back and this older vendor picked up the skillet I was holding and flat out said "that one's too far gone, put it down." It was $4, black as a tire, maybe a quarter inch of crud on the bottom, and yeah, the handle had a hairline crack near the screw hole. Here is my thing: "too far gone" is just a price. I took it home, soaked it in a lye bath for three days, hit it with a stainless scrubber, and the cooking surface underneath was smoother than anything new I could buy for under $50. The crack I filled with a dab of high heat epoxy meant for engine blocks, and it has held through maybe 20 rounds of cornbread so far with no wiggle. People at these markets judge a pan by how it looks sitting in the dirt, not by what 30 minutes of elbow grease does to it. Vendors who flip fast will always steer you to the shiny stuff because it sells itself, and the ugly ones get left for people like us. So what is your cutoff, do you buy cracked iron and fix it, or is a hairline crack a hard pass for you?