Loading…
5
My uncle dropped a pun at Thanksgiving dinner in Columbus that split the table in half
So my uncle Ray comes over for Thanksgiving at my mom's place in Columbus two years back, right in the middle of the turkey getting passed around. My cousin Beth asks him to carve it and he looks at the bird for a second all serious, then goes "I'd love to, but I'm not sure I'm qualified, I've only got a poultry amount of experience." My aunt just stares at him. My mom actually snorts into her wine. My little nephew Tyler is like 8 and he laughs so hard he almost chokes on a roll, and Ray just keeps carving like nothing happened. For the next 20 minutes every single person at that table tried to top it and every attempt flopped, my dad did one about gobble til you wobble and it was just sad. I still think about that line every November and I have never once come up with a comeback. What's the best one somebody has dropped on your family out of nowhere like that?
1 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In1 Comment
elliot_taylor26d ago
The move that works in this spot is to not try to beat the pun, just extend it. When somebody lands a line like that at the table, the best reply is usually a quick follow up that keeps the same wordplay going instead of starting a new joke. In my family the person who wins is never the one with the biggest zinger, it's the one who tags on something small like "well played, Ray, you really carved that one out" while the bird is still moving around the table. Timing matters more than the joke itself, so if you wait 20 seconds the moment is gone and everything after that lands flat, which is exactly what happened to your dad. My advice for this November is to have one short follow up ready in your head before the turkey even hits the table, something that builds on whatever pun gets dropped. Your mileage may vary since every family is different, but the short extension almost always beats a brand new joke.
5