Our rigging crew went from 6 down to 2 hand signals last month, so is cutting them good or bad?
Site super in Fort Worth said the signals were confusing so he cut the chart down to just two, and now the spotter and I keep guessing on the small stuff. Do you think fewer signals is safer, or does it just cover up bad radio habits?
Cutting down to two signals is the wrong move and the super is fooling himself if he thinks it is safer. Two signals means everything that used to have its own sign now falls into "other," and "other" is where guys get hurt because nobody agrees on what it means. The chart was not the problem, the problem was guys not drilling the signals or the spotter yelling over the radio while swinging. You fix that with practice and clear radio calls, not by throwing away half the vocabulary. A short chart just hides the confusion until a load is already moving and somebody guesses wrong. Six signals is not much to learn, and a crew that cannot keep six straight has a bigger problem than the chart.