I ignored the $8 tarp test and my tent floor paid for it in Flagstaff
Two weeks back I set up camp near Flagstaff and the ground was all sharp little rocks and pine needles. I skipped the cheap tarp under the tent because I figured the floor was tough enough, and by morning there were 3 pinholes letting damp through. A guy two spots over had the same tent and zero issues because he spent $8 on a basic tarp and cut it to fit. I patched mine with duct tape for the rest of the trip and it held, but it looked rough. Now I want to know if those precut footprint tarps are worth the extra money or if a hardware store tarp does the same job.
Man, those "sharp little rocks and pine needles" around Flagstaff are no joke, that ground eats tent floors for breakfast. I feel for you on the duct tape patch, been there and it never looks great but at least it holds. Honestly the pain of finding damp in the morning is the worst part, especially when the fix was eight bucks the whole time. That stings a little, but hey, now you know for next trip.