Man, I went through the same thing when I first moved to the hammer. What worked for me was going back to hand work for the finish passes only. The hammer is great for moving metal fast and setting the basic shape, but trying to do everything on it made me fight the tool. I spent a couple weeks just doing the heavy drawing on the hammer and then cleaning up by hand so I could feel where the metal wanted to go. Once I got a feel for how the hammer moves steel, my setup stopped feeling wrong. Honestly the second guessing is normal, it just means you noticed something changed. Give it some time and figure out which steps the hammer actually makes easier for you.