Guy at the spring hammer-in in Albany told my scrolls looked "machine bent" and it stung
I was pretty proud of the scrollwork on a fireplace set I brought to the hammer-in in Albany last spring, and an older smith named Walt looked at it for maybe 10 seconds before saying it looked machine bent. He meant it as a crit, because each curve was too even and had no life to it. So now I mark my start and end points and work the bends with my eyes on the middle of the piece instead of chasing each curve with a jig. My last set had a slight wave in one scroll and honestly it looks way better than the perfect ones, and Walt nodded at it in October. Any of you got a crit that stuck with you like that?