Walk-ins or appointments only, I picked one at my shop in Dayton and lost half my regulars
Back in 2019 I ran my chair on walk-ins only because that's how I learned it at Al's on 5th Street. When I opened my own spot I had to pick between keeping that chaos or going full appointment, so I went appointment and my Saturday crowd just stopped showing up. Two guys named Marcus and Ray who came every other Saturday for a decade never came back after I put a sign up. Any of you run a split, like appointments in the morning and walk-ins after 2, and does it actually work or is it the worst of both?
Why does losing the walk in guys always hit harder than gaining the appointment ones? Same thing happened to me in Columbus when I switched to booked only. Had this old timer named Walt who came in every Friday at 3 on the dot for a buzz and a shave, never called ahead once in four years. Put up the appointment sign and he stood outside reading it for a minute, then just walked off and I never saw him again. Tried the split thing for a couple months, appointments till 2 then walk ins, and honestly it was a mess. The booked guys got mad when a walk in ran long and pushed everything back, and the walk in guys got mad that they had to wait anyway.