A swap meet guy talking you out of something is exactly the reason you should have tossed it. Half those guys are just lonely and want someone to chat with, and now that wrench is sitting in your garage taking up space for another ten years. What's it actually worth to you if it's been out of spec this whole time? A torque wrench you can't trust is worse than no wrench at all because it gives you false confidence on head bolts and wheel lugs. The money is already gone, so keeping it doesn't get you anything back.