Found the thing that finally made artifact photos usable: a $12 piece of black poster board
I do volunteer lab work at a small museum here in Tucson and for about 8 months every sherd and point I shot looked like garbage. The colors were washed out, the textures disappeared, and my supervisor kept sending them back saying she could not tell chert from quartzite on my photos. I tried moving lamps around, I tried shooting outside on an overcast day, I even borrowed a light box from the photo department, and nothing fixed it. Then a retired guy who volunteers on Fridays watched me struggle for 20 minutes and told me to tape black poster board behind the artifact and put one lamp low on the side. Cost me $12 at the craft store and the first batch after that was night and day, edge flaking popped, and my supervisor signed off on all 30 shots on the first pass. Something about the dark background killing the bounce light and the low angle raking across the surface is what did it. Curious if any of you shooting small finds have a better backdrop setup, or do you just cave and buy a tent?