Can we talk about how ad buyers used to actually call us back?
Had lunch with a guy named Ray who ran media buying at a small agency in Columbus for 26 years, and he mentioned that back in the day a rep would drive over just to hand you a rate card. Now everything is an auction dashboard and I'm bidding against who knows who at 2am. He said the whole game got faster but nobody feels like a partner anymore, and that stuck with me. Does anyone here still get real pushback from a buyer on creative, or did that die with the fax machine?
The line about "nobody feels like a partner anymore" is where I'd push back a little. I've been buying for about 9 years now and I still get real pushback on creative all the time, honestly more than I want some weeks lol. The difference is it comes from data now instead of a gut feeling over lunch. A buyer can look at your spot and tell you exactly which 6 seconds people drop off, and that's a harder conversation than Ray probably ever had with a rep. I get that the auction stuff feels cold and impersonal at 2am, but the feedback loop is way tighter than when a guy drove over with a rate card. Feels less like a partnership and more like a scoreboard, sure, but the scoreboard still cares whether your creative works.