A quick chat with a local shop owner made me question my whole pitch approach

Last Tuesday I stopped by a small print shop outside Cleveland to pick up some flyers for a client. The owner, a guy named Pete who has run the place for 25 years, glanced at the flyer and said, "You know, nobody reads the headline first anymore. They read the price, then the picture, then maybe the headline if we get lucky." That stopped me cold. I have spent so much time crafting clever opening lines for ads, but he was talking about real behavior he sees every day with his own customers. I started thinking about how many campaigns I have built around a big idea when the actual hook was buried two paragraphs down. He told me his best flyer ever was just a bold black box with the number 40% off and nothing else. I drove home feeling like I had been overthinking this whole business for the past 10 years. Has anyone else had a similar moment where someone outside the industry pointed out something obvious you had missed?

1 comments

1 Comment

nora_walker575d ago

Haven't we all had that moment where a stranger says something so plain it makes you feel like a fool? I had a similar wake-up call when a cashier told me people just want to know what it costs and if it's easy to get. All my fancy words about brand stories and emotional connection meant nothing when the real question was just "how much and where do I go." It's humbling to realize the people who see customers every single day know way more than we do from our desks. Maybe we all need to spend more time just standing in shops and listening to what people actually say. That Pete sounds like a smart guy, and honestly, that black box flyer probably worked because it did exactly what it needed to do.