A 24-year media buyer told me to kill retargeting and put it all in prospecting, and she was right
Back in March I was running a small skincare account, about $14k a month, and I had retargeting eating 40 percent of the budget because it always showed a 6x ROAS and made my reports look great. A media buyer named Dana who I met at a Columbus meetup pulled up my account and said point blank, 'You are paying to talk to people who already know you. Go find new ones.' I fought her on it for two weeks because my gut said retargeting was the safe money. Then I dropped retargeting to 10 percent and pushed the rest into cold prospecting with new creative, and within 30 days my blended cost per purchase went from $61 to $44 while total spend stayed flat. The whole time retargeting was just claiming credit for sales that prospecting was really driving. Now my reports look worse on paper but my client's revenue is up 22 percent. Anyone else had a media buyer call out your attribution like that and get it right?