PSA: someone at the shop on Pine said a "first appearance" clue was real and it cost me $60
I was digging through a long box at the shop on Pine Street in Long Beach 3 weeks ago and the guy working there told me a beat-up issue had a first appearance clue in it, so I paid $60 without checking. Got it home, looked up the actual cover date and it was just a reprint with a sketchy label, so I went back and got my money returned after showing him the price guide. Now I screenshot the cover and date before I hand over cash anywhere. Has anyone else run into a shop worker who guesses at key issue stuff instead of just looking it up?
Oh man, this hits home! A guy at a shop near me pulled the same thing with a "key issue" that turned out to be a second print, and of course he "forgot" to mention that part. I was new to collecting then and didn't know to check the small print on the inside page, so I ate the loss on that one. Now I do the exact same thing you do (phone out, cover pic, date check) before any cash leaves my hand. It stinks that we have to be our own fact checkers, but a worker guessing at keys is worse than no help at all.